While a person found with five grams of crack cocaine faced a fiveyear mandatory minimum prison sentence. In a speech to the national urban league last week, president obama said that the bill would help right a longstanding wrong by narrowing sentencing disparities between those. Are there any possible arguments in favor of sentencing. House holds hearings on crackpowder cocaine sentencing. After the passage of the act, possession of 28 grams of crack cocaine constituted a felony offense or 500 grams of power cocaine, as beforean 18to1 disparity. The 100to1 crack cocaine to powder cocaine quantity ratio is a primary cause of the growing disparity between sentences for black and white federal defendants, the commission wrote. The american civil liberties union filed a friendofthecourt brief in the case, kimbrough v. This report addresses disparities in cocaine sentencing in states and documents efforts at the federal and state level to correct these injustices. Sentencing commission, a federal agency, found that crack cocaine is not appreciably different from powder cocaine, either in its chemical composition or the physical reactions of its users. A comprehensive examination of the 100to1 crack versus powder cocaine sentencing disparity under which distribution of just 5 grams of crack carries a. The reform s reduce the sentencing disparity between powder and crack cocaine quantities from 100to1 to 18to1, and eliminate mandatory sentences for possession of small amounts of crack.
Term paper on sentencing disparities between crack cocaine vs. Powder assignment the disparity in the sentencing illustrates that congress considered crack cocaine much more dangerous than powder cocaine and as a result, those who trafficked crack. Since 2003 connecticut, iowa and south carolina have adopted reforms to address their sentencing disparities. To assess racial disparity at the time of sentencing, the commission used an ordinary least squares ols regression model, with the length of the prison term as the dependent variable, the minimum recommended sentence range as the principal covariates, and race and sex as multiplicative factors.
Sentencing commission has been a program responsible for this in the past and present. An example of sentencing disparity is if a threetime offender in one jurisdiction receives 5 years for armed robbery, whereas a threetime offender in another jurisdiction receives 15 years for the same offense. In the sentencing commissions report on the crackpowder cocaine sentencing disparity released in february, it pointed to the racial impact of this law. Before the passage of the fair sentencing act in the united states in 2010, possession of 5 grams of crack cocaine, or 500 grams of powder cocaine, constituted a felony offensea 100to1 disparity.
The history of racial disparity in the criminal justice system in the u. How an early biden crime bill created the sentencing. Sentencing disparities between crack cocaine 2005, february 21 retrieved april 28, 2020, from. Similarly, those carrying ten grams of crack cocaine faced a. Proposals to eliminate sentencing disparities between crack and powder cocaine offenses. The key word in discussing unwarranted sentence disparities is unwarranted. Racial disparities and fiscal consequences of americas drug laws abstract in 1986, the united states government attempted to combat the perceived war on drugs by enacting mandatory drug laws, with a primary focus on incarcerating crack offenders. Analysis of racial sentencing disparities reading the world. Figure 1 highlights the differences in average sentences between crack and powder. The house of representatives passed a bill on wednesday that would reduce the disparities between mandatory federal sentences for crack and powder cocaine violations, a. Now, those sent into treatment have only a 36 percent chance of committing a repeat offense, versus 54 percent for those incarcerated before the new law went into effect. Africanamericans and hispanics are more than twice as likely as whites to be searched, arrested, or.
And few prison systems are bigger or more expensive than californias. The legislation also eliminates the mandatory minimum for simple possession of crack cocaine. Racial, ethnic, and gender disparities in federal sentencing today a. Because crack and powder cocaine are two forms of the same drug, there should not be any disparity in sentencing between crack and powder cocaine offenses the only truly fair ratio is 1. Whereas, the fiveyear federal mandatory minimum sentencing amount for cocaine base hereinafter crack is five grams and the corresponding amount for cocaine hydrochloride hereinafter powder cocaineis 500 gms. The results of the studies indicate thatracially discriminatory sentencing persists despite. Africanamericans now serve virtually as much time in prison for a drug offense 58. Fair sentencing act american civil liberties union. Congress moves to narrow sentencing disparities for crack.
Today, states maintain sentencing disparities between crack and powder cocaine offenses. One commonly known disparity created in the sentencing guidelines used today is the lengthier sentences for drug charges on crack cocaine that creates racial disparities because crack cocaine is cheaper to obtain than the powder cocaine. The report finds that over 88% of those sentenced for crack offenses are black, while only 4. As a result of the legislation, those arrested for offenses involving crack cocaine faced much steeper punishments than those arrested for those involving powder cocaine. Sentence disparity law and legal definition uslegal, inc. At the height of americas war on drugs, from the 1980s through the mid2000s, more than 20 prisons opened in california, compared with just 12 between 1852 and 1984. The house, by voice vote, approved a bill reducing the disparities between mandatory crack and powder cocaine sentences, sending the measure to president barack obama for his signature. The racial dynamics in sentencing have changed over time and reflect a move from explicit racism to more surreptitious manifestations and outcomes.
Disparity in sentencing for crack vs powder cocaine. Examples such as the sentencing disparity between crack cocaine and powdered cocaine. The disparity between crack sentences and sentences for powdered cocaine has existed since the reagan era, when the united states experienced a supposed epidemic of crack addiction an epidemic that was exaggerated by the media. Sentencing disparity is defined as a form of unequal treatment in criminal punishment that is often of unexplained cause and is at least incongruous, unfair and disadvantaging in consequence.
Sentencing disparities between minority and white defendants also narrowed by onethird. Unwarranted disparity is defined as different treatment of individual offenders who are similar in relevant ways, or similar treatment of individual. At the time, possession of crack cocaine resulted in penalties 100 times higher than possession of an equal amount of the powdered form. Reforming mandatory minimums law enforcement leaders. The stark difference in federal sentencing laws for possession of the two forms of the same drug has more to do with media mythology and political pressure than with public safety and health. In 2010, congress passed the fair sentencing act fsa, which reduced the sentencing disparity between offenses for crack and powder cocaine from 100. The changing racial dynamics of womens incarceration. Crack and cocaine powder sentencing disparities essay sample.
Disparity, discrimination, and adverse impacts fair sentencing is individualized sentencing. Drug sentencing policies are widely blamed for the enormous size and costs of the countrys prison systems. Sentence disparity law and legal definition sentence disparity refers to an inequality in criminal sentencing which is the result of unfair or unexplained causes, rather than a legitimate use of discretion in the application of the law. Cracking the racial disparity for cocaine sentencing. What is the chemical difference between crack cocaine and powder cocaine. White america does the crime, black america gets the time. Although the architects of the war on drugs may not have intended for the racial disparities. Solutions for fixing the sentencing disparities between whites and blacks include both reducing the gap and eliminating it all together. A 2010 federal law rectified some, though not all, of the sentencing disparities. Disparity definition, lack of similarity or equality. Crack and cocaine powder sentencing disparities essay.
Aspirations and realism about drug sentencing reform that disparities in sentencing continue to plague the criminal justice system. Data show racial disparity in crack sentencing us news. The sentencing project cracked justice crack cocaine. Congress passed the fair sentencing act to make punishments for. Both discrimination and disparity exists within the criminal justice system at one stage or another. Furthermore, 35 of the 40 studies only analyze sentencing outcomes in jurisdictions and periods that have implemented some version of a determinate or guidelinesbased sentencing structure, designed, in part, to eliminate racial disparities in sentencing. What type of sentence is work release, whereby a person is consigned to a special portion of the jail on weekends and nights, but released to go to work during the day. But in 1986 congress defined serious traffickers as the managers of the. While eliminating the crackpowder sentencing disparity is a critical step, it is not sufficient to reintroduce fairness and proportionality into federal sentencing laws. Today states maintain sentencing disparities between crack and powder cocaine offenses. Reducing racial disparities in incarceration give em hell. A 1986 drug bill instituted different sentencing guidelines for two different forms of the same drug cocaine.
Connecticut equalized penalties for crack and powder in 2005. Racial disparity in sentencing open society foundations. John conyers, dmichigan, recently contended that the new law will reduce sentencing disparity between crack and powder cocaine from. This disparity between crack and powder cocaine was driven by fear.
Iowa modified the state sentencing disparity in 2003 from 100to1 to 10to1. Sentencing theories have fluctuated between two extremes. This happens because of the disproportionate sentencing amongst the races with the crimes that are committed. How many states maintain sentencing disparities between crack and powder cocaine. The new law significantly reduces the cocaine sentencing quantity disparity from 100 to 1 to 18 to 1 by raising the quantity of crack cocaine necessary to trigger the five and tenyear mandatory minimum sentences first set in 1986. We wrote this paper to inform the public and congress about the disparities in the sentencing laws between crack and powder cocaine, which.
Socioeconomically disadvantaged adults are more likely to use crack over powder cocaine, and are thus more likely to be subject to arrest. Assistant majority leader dick durbin dil introduced the fair sentencing act of 2009, a narrowlytailored bill that would eliminate the sentencing disparity between crack and powder cocaine and increase penalties for the worst offenders. From arrest, to sentencing, to incarceration, and on to reintegration, race has played a significant role in the war on drugs. The us sentencing commission provided this analogy in 1997 to support equalizing penalties for crack and powder cocaine. The fair sentencing act amends existing laws by increasing the amounts of crack that trigger these penalties, from five grams to 28 grams for fiveyear minimum sentences and from 50 grams to 280 grams for tenyear minimum sentences. In the three decades prior to the passing of the fair sentencing act, those who were arrested for possessing crack cocaine faced much more severe penalties than those in possession of powder cocaine. To do that requires changing sentencing guidelines and laws. Federal crack cocaine sentencing the sentencing project. Report to the united nations on racial disparities in the u. This year, advocates in several states have held rallies or protests designed.
567 593 404 432 402 975 1206 250 789 586 418 1197 746 1444 365 1476 374 548 1188 572 507 1451 20 49 1492 1227 294 48 977 1460 741 154 634 920 515 1483 1119 98 923